ON THE WIRE
NOW LIVE — Verdicts, rankings, and community scoresBG3 scores a perfect 10 — our first S+ gradeGTA VI drops November 2026 — on our radarMarvel’s Wolverine · SEP 15 — verdict incomingCommunity board waiting for votes — be the first10 rankings live — Best Games Like Hades, BG3, Elden Ring and moreSony Is Being Sued for $457 Million for Killing the DiscHellblade. Psychonauts. State of Decay. Xbox Was Closing These Studios. They Fought Back and Won.GTA 6 Will Probably Be the Best Game in Years. It's Also Setting the Worst Precedents.PlayStation Is Killing the Disc. All New Games Go Digital-Only from January 2028.The List Is Growing: Undead Labs Is Now the Fourth Xbox Studio Facing the AxeBungie Announces Layoffs — Destiny 2 Is Done and the Studio Reorganizes Around MarathonLISTBest Games Like HadesLISTBest Games Like FortniteLISTBest Games Like Stardew ValleyNOW LIVE — Verdicts, rankings, and community scoresBG3 scores a perfect 10 — our first S+ gradeGTA VI drops November 2026 — on our radarMarvel’s Wolverine · SEP 15 — verdict incomingCommunity board waiting for votes — be the first10 rankings live — Best Games Like Hades, BG3, Elden Ring and moreSony Is Being Sued for $457 Million for Killing the DiscHellblade. Psychonauts. State of Decay. Xbox Was Closing These Studios. They Fought Back and Won.GTA 6 Will Probably Be the Best Game in Years. It's Also Setting the Worst Precedents.PlayStation Is Killing the Disc. All New Games Go Digital-Only from January 2028.The List Is Growing: Undead Labs Is Now the Fourth Xbox Studio Facing the AxeBungie Announces Layoffs — Destiny 2 Is Done and the Studio Reorganizes Around MarathonLISTBest Games Like HadesLISTBest Games Like FortniteLISTBest Games Like Stardew Valley
REVIEWSurvival horror · solo · 18h

Alan Wake 2

A sequel 13 years in the making. Worth every year of the wait.

Alan Wake 2
PS5XSXPC

YOU’LL LOVE IT IF…

  • Players who want authored artistic vision over mechanical polish
  • Horror fans drawn to psychological and surrealist dread rather than jump scares
  • Remedy fans who've followed the connected universe through Alan Wake 1 and Control

SKIP IT IF…

  • Players who want tight, satisfying combat as their primary loop
  • Those unfamiliar with Remedy's universe who don't want lore homework
  • Players who need 4K/60fps without compromise on base hardware

Score breakdown

Gameplay7.5
Story9.0
Audio9.0
Visuals9.5
Value7.0

The Review

Alan Wake 2 released in October 2023 and immediately established itself as one of the most visually and conceptually ambitious games of the generation. Remedy built a dual-narrative structure where you alternate between FBI agent Saga Anderson investigating cult murders in Cauldron Lake and Alan Wake trapped in a nightmare dimension called the Dark Place. The two stories interweave in ways that are deliberately disorienting.

The game's live-action sequences - full musical numbers, talk show segments, and FMV cutscenes spliced into the in-engine world - are unlike anything in mainstream gaming. The Scratch musical sequence in particular became a touchstone moment discussed for months after launch. Remedy's Northlight engine produces some of the best real-time lighting in the medium, and the Dark Place sequences lean into this with environments that feel painted rather than rendered.

The survival horror combat is competent but secondary to the experience - those expecting Resident Evil-style tension may find the gunplay underwhelming. The story demands familiarity with the first game and Control to fully land, which limits its accessibility. The PC version at launch had significant performance issues that were largely addressed in subsequent patches. This is a game made by people with real creative conviction, and that conviction is palpable in every chapter.

+ THE GOOD

  • Live-action sequences and meta-narrative ambition are unmatched in AAA
  • The Dark Place visual design is some of the best environmental art of the generation
  • Dual protagonist structure gives the story genuine structural complexity

− THE BAD

  • Combat is serviceable but never thrilling - more obstacle than joy
  • Requires knowledge of Alan Wake 1 and Control for full narrative payoff
  • PC performance at launch was rough; patches improved it significantly
BUYNEXT SAVE POINT

Final word: Buy it.

Alan Wake 2 earns a 8.0/10 (A-) and a BUY from Kirtted. Best on PS5. Worth your time? KINDA.

Verdicts are ours alone — never paid for, never previewed by publishers.
MORE VERDICTS

Fresh off the board

// NEWSLETTER

NO HYPE.
JUST GAMES.

Verdict drops, ranking updates, and the gaming news that actually matters — straight to your inbox. No sponsors. No fluff. Unsubscribe anytime.

YOUR EMAIL

No spam. No paid placements. Unsubscribe with one click.

Getting a security error? Reload the page and wait for the Cloudflare checkbox to appear before submitting.